Schedule your meetings now
Your car is still running, the other one is angled oddly across both lanes, and you’re standing between them trying to decide what you’re even supposed to do first. Someone behind you has already stopped and is asking if you’re okay. You nod, though you’re not sure that’s true. You pull out your phone, unsure whether to call 911, take pictures, or write something down before you forget it.
Every second you stand there deciding feels like it might matter later. New York Auto Law understands how much clearer these first few minutes need to be, and we step in to walk you through exactly what to do before you leave the scene.
What Are the Right Steps to Take After An Accident?
What to do after a car accident in Buffalo comes down to a simple order of operations: get everyone medical attention first, document the scene next, report the crash as required by New York law, and only then start talking to insurance companies. Each step protects the one after it, so skipping ahead, especially straight to a phone call with an adjuster, can cost you information you cannot get back later.
The Car Accident Checklist for Buffalo
Step 1: Check Yourself and Everyone Else for Injuries First
Look at yourself and everyone else in both cars before anything else; adrenaline hides pain well enough that a real injury can go unnoticed for the first few minutes. A stiff neck, a headache that will not quit, or a dull ache in your back can all be early signs of whiplash or a concussion, injuries that often do not announce themselves until the next morning. If you or anyone else needs to go straight to the hospital, go. Leaving the scene in an ambulance does not forfeit a claim; the case just gets built from medical records, the police report, and other witnesses instead of your own photos.
If anything feels off in the days after the crash, even something minor, seeing a doctor creates the same kind of record as a same-day visit would. A passenger in either car has their own separate claim, and their injuries deserve the same attention as the drivers’. Do not overlook a passenger’s discomfort just because the conversation naturally focuses on the two people driving.
Step 2: Call the Police and Exchange Information Before Anyone Leaves
Call the police even if the crash looks minor and everyone seems fine, since Buffalo winters bring hidden risks like black ice and reduced visibility that a report can capture better than you can recall. New York law also requires every driver involved to stop, show their license and insurance, and exchange that information with the other driver before leaving. Get more than a name and a phone number: the other driver’s insurance company and policy number, their license plate, and the make and model of their car.
If anyone stopped to watch, get their name and phone number too. A witness’s name and number are worth more than their account of what happened on the spot, since what someone recalls tends to soften over time, and a phone number does not. Ask the other driver to wait for the police to arrive rather than settling things between yourselves, since an officer’s report becomes an independent record of what each person said at the time, before anyone’s account starts to shift.
Saying sorry in the middle of all this is a natural reflex; most people say it after any collision without meaning to admit fault, but it can get repeated back later as though it were an admission, so it is worth holding back even when staying quiet feels rude.
Step 3: Photograph the Scene like an Investigator Would
Most people photograph the dented bumper and stop there. That photo matters, but it is rarely the one that decides a disputed claim, and Western New York crashes rarely get the kind of full police reconstruction that would capture anything more. Photograph what you think an investigator would look for instead, including:
- The traffic light or stop sign controlling the intersection;
- The street signs, so you know exactly where this happened;
- A wide shot of the whole intersection or block;
- The skid marks before rain or the next round of traffic erases them;
- The positioning of the cars next to each other and their damage;
- The location each car finally came to rest before anyone moved them; and
- Any ice, snow, or road debris around or part of the accident.
A written report might only mention these things in passing, but your photographs will help as evidence throughout the case.
Step 4: Write Down What You Remember While It Is Fresh
Our memories fade faster than most people expect, sometimes within hours, and especially when we’re in shock. Before you leave the scene, or as soon after as you can manage, write down the time, the direction each car was traveling, what the weather and road looked like, and anything the other driver said, in their own words if you can recall it.
Note what you were doing in the seconds before impact, too, even something as simple as approaching a green light, since a detail that feels obvious in the moment is often the first thing to get fuzzy by the time an adjuster asks about it weeks later. A note in your own phone, timestamped and dated automatically, holds up better than trying to reconstruct the sequence from scratch a month down the road.
Steps to Take After a Car Accident in NY
New York requires a separate report to the Department of Motor Vehicles within 10 days of any crash that causes an injury, a death, or more than $1,000 in damage to any one person’s property, filed as the MV-104. This applies to every driver involved, not just whoever caused the crash, so being certain the other driver was at fault does not get you out of filing your own report.
A lot of drivers assume that once a police officer responds and files a report, that requirement disappears. It does not. The MV-104 form itself treats a police response as a separate detail to note, not as a substitute for your own filing, and the statute’s one narrow exception protects only an on-duty police officer, corrections officer, or firefighter from a late report, and only if the vehicle’s owner already filed one. It does not excuse an ordinary driver whose crash a responding officer happened to investigate. You can file the MV-104 online through the DMV’s crash reporting site or by mail; either way, missing the 10 days can result in a misdemeanor charge and a hold on your license or registration until the report is filed.
Not every minor crash gets an officer on scene. Buffalo Police, like departments across the state, do not always respond to a fender bender with no injuries and no blocked traffic. When that happens, your own MV-104 becomes the only official record of the crash that exists anywhere, which makes filling it out completely, not just quickly, worth the extra 10 minutes it takes.
Separately, your own no-fault paperwork runs on its own clock: written notice to your insurer is due within 30 days. Missing either the DMV report or the no-fault notice creates a problem with your case that has nothing to do with who caused the crash. Keep a copy of whatever you submit, whether you file online or by mail, so you have your own proof of the date if a question about the deadline ever comes up.
What to Say, and Not Say, to an Insurance Adjuster
An insurance adjuster’s job includes managing what the company pays out, and the words you choose on that first call can shape how your claim gets valued from that point forward. They will try to get a recorded statement from you as quickly as possible, but resist doing so until you talk to a lawyer. Initially, if you must talk to an insurance company:
- Stick to the basic facts. Where, when, and what happened, without guessing at speed, distance, or anything you did not actually see.
- Skip the apology. Saying sorry after a crash is a normal reflex, not an admission of fault, but it rarely gets read that way once it is written into a claims file.
- Hold off on describing your injuries. Since adrenaline can mask pain for hours or days, an early statement that undersells an injury can follow the claim later.
- Keep the crash off social media. Even a vague post about being in an accident, or a photo from an unrelated trip taken while you are supposedly too hurt to work, can end up in front of an adjuster looking for a reason to dispute how serious the injury actually is.
- Do not accept the first offer. An initial number is often written to appear reasonable enough to accept quickly, rather than to reflect what the claim is worth once it is fully documented.
Notifying your own insurer is still part of maintaining your policy. The difference is in treating every recorded word as something that becomes part of your file.
When Should You Call a Car Accident Lawyer in Buffalo?
Not every crash needs a lawyer immediately; a fender bender with no injury and no dispute over fault is often something you can close out yourself. Call one when an injury needs ongoing treatment, when the other driver’s insurer disputes what happened, when a commercial truck or multiple vehicles are involved, or when an adjuster starts pushing for a quick answer before you know how serious an injury actually is. A crash that looked minor at the scene can turn into a real claim once an injury shows up two days later, and that shift alone is reason enough to get a second opinion before signing anything.
The steps to take after a car accident in NY cover the paperwork and the deadlines, but they do not weigh in on whether a settlement number actually reflects what your claim is worth. A car accident checklist for Buffalo drivers helps you through the first hours and the forms that follow. Still, it cannot tell you how a specific insurer typically handles a specific type of injury, or whether the number on an offer is fair for what you are actually dealing with. Knowing when to bring in a lawyer is the one step no checklist can make for you.
Why New York Auto Law Builds Every Case from the Scene Forward
Most crashes in Western New York never get a formal police reconstruction; that level of investigation is reserved for the most serious collisions, which means the steps a driver takes in the first hours after a crash often become the only record of what actually happened. New York Auto Law treats those early hours as part of the case from the moment a client calls, gathering the same kind of evidence an investigator would look for as soon as they first get the lead. The strength of your claim will come from a team that already knows how to build a case from exactly this kind of evidence, based on decades of legal experience.
You Do Not Have to Get Every Step Right on Your Own
What to do after a car accident in Buffalo does not end once the tow truck pulls away, and a missed form or an early phone call you wish you could take back does not have to define your case. New York Auto Law can look at what happened, tell you plainly where your claim stands, and help you sort out what still needs to be done. Reach out for a free case review whenever you are ready to talk through what happened.
Legal References Used to Inform This Page
To ensure the accuracy and clarity of this page, we referenced official legal and other resources during the content development process:
- Leaving scene of an incident without reporting, N.Y. Veh. & Traf. Law § 600 (2022).
- Report required upon accident, N.Y. Veh. & Traf. Law § 605 (2025).
- New York Department of Motor Vehicles, When You Need to File a Crash Report.
- Requirements for minimum benefit insurance policies for personal injuries, 11 N.Y.C.R.R. § 65-1.1 (2023).
Michael Greenspan has been deeply involved in the affairs of his community for his entire professional career. Mike has been a certified high school track and field official since 1992 and has officiated at prestigious invitational meets as well as the New York State Championships. Additionally, Mike has served as a member of the Executive Committee of the Glenn D. Loucks Games at his alma mater, White Plains High School since 1991 and as a member of the Board of Directors of the JCC-Rockland.