Maybe the driver admitted at the scene that he had been behind the wheel since before sunrise. Maybe the trooper’s report noted brakes out of adjustment, or a search of the carrier’s public safety record turned up a string of roadside violations in the months before the crash. Each points to the same suspicion that the trucking company broke a federal rule.
Those rules are the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Regulations, which the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) issues to govern how long drivers may drive, how trucks must be maintained, and who is qualified to operate them. In New York, proof that a carrier violated one of these rules does not, by itself, prove negligence.
That distinction shapes how a case should be built. New York Auto Law has represented injured New Yorkers since 1959. As FMCSA violation truck accident lawyers, we focus on linking the rule the carrier broke to the mechanics of your crash, and on moving to secure the logs and inspection files before the carrier can lawfully discard them. Contact our team for a free consultation.
How Can a Regulation Violation Open the Door?
New York’s negligence per se rule dates to 1920, when the state’s highest court held that the unexcused violation of a statute is negligence in itself. The court has since limited that rule to laws passed by the State Legislature. Violating a regulation issued by a state agency, or a local ordinance, is only some evidence of negligence.
The federal trucking rules are regulations issued by a federal agency, not statutes passed by Congress. New York has adopted them as state regulations, so they apply on New York roads, and New York extends most of them to trucks that never leave the state, with some exemptions. Adoption, however, does not turn them into statutes, so a violation remains only some evidence of negligence.
That leaves three things to prove in every case built on FMCSA violations:
- The rule applied,
- The rule was broken, and
- The violation contributed to the crash.
Whether the rule applied usually depends on the vehicle. The federal regulations govern commercial motor vehicles, including those with a gross vehicle weight rating or gross combination weight rating of 10,001 pounds or more used in interstate commerce, as well as certain passenger vehicles and vehicles carrying enough hazardous material to require warning placards.
The third element, causation, is where the defense concentrates its effort. Consider a driver whose medical certificate lapsed a week before the crash, in which the truck rear-ended a stopped car. The violation is real, but its connection to the impact is thin. Compare a driver who exceeded the federal 11-hour driving limit and then drifted across a lane line on the Thruway. Fatigue can explain the drift, and a separate federal rule forbids driving while too fatigued to operate safely.
When the Driver’s Traffic Violation Does More Work Than the Federal Rule
A DOT violation truck accident claim often has a second layer. Following too closely, changing lanes unsafely, and driving too fast for conditions all violate the Vehicle and Traffic Law, and an unexcused violation of that law is negligence per se. The two kinds of violations work together: the traffic violation can establish the driver’s negligence as a matter of law, and the federal violation can explain why it happened and what the company knew.
Hiring violations, such as a missing background check or a lapsed medical certificate, often add less than they seem. Once the company admits its driver was acting within the scope of employment, it is already liable for the driver’s negligence, and a New York court will usually dismiss a separate negligent hiring claim as unnecessary. Those violations matter most when the case seeks punitive damages, which require proof of the company’s own gross negligence, such as knowingly dispatching a dangerous driver.
How Long Must a Carrier Maintain Records?
The regulations require carriers to keep records only for set periods. Minimum periods include:
- Hours of service records—maintained for six months and include electronic logging device data;
- Driver vehicle inspection reports (DVIRs)—three months from the date the report was prepared by a driver who finds a defect;
- Roadside inspection reports—12 months from the date of inspection;
- Maintenance records—one year from where the vehicle is housed, and for six months after the vehicle leaves the carrier’s control;
- Annual inspection reports—maintained for 14 months;
- Driver qualification files—three years after the driver leaves the company, although some documents in them may be discarded sooner;
- Accident registers—three years;
- Negative drug test results and alcohol test results below 0.02—one year; and
- Verified positive drug test results, alcohol test results of 0.02 or higher, and refusals to test—five years.
At the end of these time periods, destruction is lawful unless a duty to preserve has arisen.
Focus on Roadside Inspection Report
The roadside inspection report deserves particular attention. If an inspector found defective brakes on the truck a month before your crash, the carrier was required to certify the repair in writing. A certification that does not match the maintenance file is the kind of evidence that connects a paperwork violation to a failed component.
A roadside inspection can also result in an out-of-service order, issued when a defect is serious enough that the truck cannot continue. No one may operate a vehicle marked out of service until the required repairs are completed. If the truck that struck you was back on the road before those repairs were made, and the uncorrected defect played a role in the crash, the link between the broken rule and the crash is direct.
Retention Period Requirements Are Broad
The six-month retention period also covers more than the driver’s logs. Carriers must keep supporting documents for each day a driver is on duty, including bills of lading, dispatch records, and fuel and other expense receipts. Each of these carries its own times and locations. A driver who logged hours of rest while the truck was being fueled 200 miles away has a log that cannot be trusted, and comparing the log to these documents is often how such falsification is exposed.
How Do You Hold the Carrier to Its Own Paper Trail?
New York law gives you several ways to secure these records. Even before a lawsuit is filed, a court can order the carrier to disclose information needed to bring the case or to preserve evidence that might otherwise be lost, which typically requires a showing that your claim has merit. Once the lawsuit begins, the carrier must disclose all material and necessary information to your claim.
What Happens to Destroyed Records?
If records are destroyed, the court can impose sanctions. You must show that:
- There was a duty to preserve the evidence when it was destroyed,
- The carrier acted with a culpable state of mind, and
- Any evidence destroyed was relevant to your claim.
When the destruction was intentional or willful, the court presumes the evidence was relevant. Sanctions range from an instruction allowing the jury to infer that the missing logs would have hurt the carrier to striking the carrier’s answer entirely, with the most severe sanctions generally reserved for cases in which the loss leaves you unable to prove your claim.
How Are Government Records Handled?
Some records come from the government rather than the carrier. A carrier’s inspection and crash history, including past FMCSA violations found during roadside inspections, is publicly available from the FMCSA. Individual inspection reports can be requested from the agency under the Freedom of Information Act.
Trucks That Cross the Peace Bridge
Buffalo is a major commercial gateway on the northern border, and many trucks on the I-190 and the Thruway are operated by Canadian carriers. The federal regulations define interstate commerce to include transportation between a place in the United States and a place outside it, so a Canadian carrier operating in New York must follow the same hours-of-service, inspection, and driver-qualification rules as a domestic carrier. Its records, however, may be kept in another country, which makes identifying the carrier, its USDOT number, and its history of FMCSA violations early all the more important.
What Changed for Truck Crash Claims in 2026?
Several recent changes at both the federal and state level have impacted the handling of truck crash claims.
FMCSA Rule Changes
FMCSA’s final rule restricting non-domiciled commercial driver’s licenses took effect on March 16, 2026. FMCSA has also enforced the English proficiency requirement as an out-of-service violation, revised its roadside enforcement guidance, and proposed codifying that out-of-service status. These violations carry weight when they explain how the crash happened, such as when a driver could not read a posted lane-closure warning.
The 2026 Amendments
New York’s 2026 amendment changed the fault rules for motor vehicle injury cases covered by the state’s no-fault law. In lawsuits commenced on or after May 26, 2026, if your share of fault is greater than that of the defendant, or of all the defendants combined, you cannot recover. Before this change, New York reduced your recovery by your percentage of fault but never barred it.
The same law eliminated the serious injury category for a temporary injury that kept a person from substantially all of their usual daily activities for 90 of the first 180 days after the crash. It also requires juries to decide fault before deciding whether an injury is serious enough to support a claim for pain and suffering. Under these rules, your fault percentage can decide whether you recover anything at all.
When a carrier claims your car cut in front of its truck, evidence that its driver was over hours, or that its brakes failed a roadside inspection, can change how a jury divides responsibility.
The Rulebook Was Written for the People Beside the Truck
In New York, a broken federal rule helps your case only when it explains how the crash happened, and proving that link usually depends on records the carrier may lawfully discard within months. Evidence that shifts responsibility onto the carrier can also decide whether you recover anything at all. An FMCSA violation truck accident lawyer can identify the violation that matters in your case and pursue the records before they are gone.
The mission of New York Auto Lawis to see that the safety rules written for the trucking industry protect the drivers, passengers, and pedestrians who share the road with a fully loaded tractor-trailer, because those are the people the rules were written for. When a carrier ignores those rules and you are hurt, we use its violations to show what went wrong and to seek compensation from the company for your injuries. If a commercial truck injured you or a family member in Buffalo, contact us for a free consultation.
Legal References Used to Inform This Page
To ensure the accuracy and clarity of this page, we referenced official legal and other resources during the content development process:
- Definitions, N.Y. Ins. Law §§ 5102(d) (2026).
- Causes of action for personal injury, N.Y. Ins. Law § 5104(a) (2026).
- Damages recoverable when contributory negligence or assumption of risk is established, N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 1411(a), (b) (2026).
- New York adoption of federal motor carrier safety regulations, 17 N.Y. C.R.R. Part 820.
- Driver’s record of duty status, 49 C.F.R. § 395.8(k).
- Reports and records, 49 U.S.C. 504 (2026).
- Detailed hazardous materials incident reports, 49 C.F.R. 171.16.
- Driver vehicle inspection report(s), 49 C.F.R. § 396.11.
- Reports and records, 49 U.S.C. § 504(f).
- Retention of alcohol and controlled substances testing records, 49 C.F.R. § 382.401.
- Accident register, 49 C.F.R. § 390.15(b).
- Maximum driving time for property-carrying vehicles, 49 C.F.R. § 395.3.
- Supporting documents 49 C.F.R. § 395.11.
- Periodic inspection recordkeeping requirements, 49 C.F.R. § 396.21(b).
- Restoring Integrity to the Issuance of Non-Domiciled Commercial Drivers Licenses (CDL), 91 Fed. Reg. 7044 (Feb. 13, 2026).
- Martin v. Herzog, 228 N.Y. 164 (1920).
- Karoon v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth., 241 A.D.2d 323 (1st Dep’t 1997).

