An underride crash happens when a passenger vehicle slides beneath the rear or side of a tractor-trailer or other large truck. Because the trailer rides higher than the car’s hood, the car’s front can pass under the truck, and the steel can enter the space where the driver and passengers sit. These crashes are often fatal. When someone dies, New York law allows a wrongful death suit against those responsible.
If an underride accident took someone you love in Buffalo or elsewhere in Erie County, speak as soon as possible with an underride accident lawyer Buffalo families can rely on. Your family can likely bring a wrongful death suit, with the claim potentially reaching the trucking company, the trailer owner, a repair shop, or the maker of a failed underride guard.
New York Auto Law has represented injured New Yorkers and grieving families since 1959. If you are filing suit on behalf of a deceased loved one, we can help open the estate in Surrogate’s Court, demand in writing that the trucking company preserve the trailer and its guard, and pursue the wrongful death claim against every responsible company. You owe no legal fee unless we recover compensation. Contact New York Auto Law for a free consultation.
Why Must the Estate Exist Before Filing a Lawsuit?
No spouse, parent, or child may file a New York wrongful death action in their own name. The claim belongs to the personal representative, who is the executor named in a will or an administrator appointed by the Surrogate’s Court.
The two-year period for filing a claim runs from the date of death, so a person who survived the crash for three weeks has a later deadline than one who died at the scene. A pending application for appointment as the representative does not stop the clock. If the defendant faces a criminal case arising from the crash, the representative has at least one year after the case ends to sue the defendant.
Any recovery goes to the decedent’s distributees, the close relatives who inherit under state law, usually a spouse and children. Each receives a share in proportion to their financial loss. A court generally must approve any settlement. An unmarried partner or stepchild who is not a distributee generally receives nothing.
Where Do the Underride Guard Rules Stop?
Federal rules require that most trailers and semitrailers rated at 10,000 pounds or more, built on or after January 26, 1998, carry a rear underride guard. The guard must meet the safety standards in effect at the time the trailer was built. Its bottom edge may sit no more than 22 inches above the ground, and it must reach within 4 inches of each side of the trailer. New York has adopted these federal rules through its own regulations, and federal annual inspection standards cover the guard. A bent, cracked, or missing underride guard is therefore a maintenance issue as well as a design issue.
A 2022 federal rule requires rear underride guards on newly built trailers to protect people in a car that strikes the trailer at 35 miles per hour, up from 30 miles per hour. Manufacturers had to comply by July 15, 2024. An older trailer may legally carry a weaker guard. The rule also addresses crashes where at least half of the car’s width overlaps the trailer, so narrower offset crashes are not covered. Pole trailers and certain low-chassis, special-purpose, and wheels-back designs are exempt.
No federal rule requires a side guard. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration sought comment on the subject in 2023, and its advisory committee urged a mandate in 2024. The Stop Underrides Act 2.0, introduced in February 2026, would direct that rule, but it has not become law.
A guard that met the federal standard does not automatically end a claim. Federal law provides that meeting a safety standard does not by itself exempt a company from common law liability, although a defendant may still argue that compliance shows it acted reasonably.
What If the Defense Says Your Loved One Hit the Truck?
In a rear underride accident, your family may start at a disadvantage. New York presumes that a driver who strikes a stopped vehicle from behind was negligent, unless there is a non-negligent explanation.
The truck driver’s own conduct can supply that explanation. Some obligations placed on drivers include:
- Moving a vehicle off the paved or main-traveled part of a highway when it is reasonable to do so,
- Turning on flashers immediately and setting out warning devices within 10 minutes when stopped on a highway or shoulder outside of ordinary traffic,
- Maintaining working lamps and reflective markings,
- Backing up or pulling across a road in a safe manner, and
- Exercising extreme caution in snow and other poor weather conditions.
Although your family is not held to as high a degree of proof in a wrongful death case as an injured person who can testify, your family must still offer some evidence from which negligence can be inferred under a rule known as the Noseworthy doctrine.
In motor vehicle injury lawsuits filed on or after May 26, 2026, a person who is more at fault than all of the defendants combined recovers nothing. It is not yet clear whether this rule applies to wrongful death. The older part of the law expressly covers wrongful death and a decedent’s fault, while the new part mentions neither. That wording supports the argument that your family’s recovery is reduced by your loved one’s share of fault, not barred. Insurers may argue otherwise.
Following the Trailer Past the Driver
A stopped truck and a failed guard may point to different defendants, such as:
- The driver and carrier. A trucking company generally answers for its employee’s negligence, and it has its own duty to inspect and repair its equipment.
- The trailer owner. A vehicle owner, including the owner of a trailer, is generally liable for the negligence of a driver using it with permission. The federal Graves Amendment shields a business that rents or leases vehicles from this liability, unless the business was negligent itself.
- A repair shop. A contractor usually owes no duty to strangers, but one exception applies when its work launches a force or instrument of harm. A shop whose weld weakened a guard may fit that exception.
- The manufacturer. A maker can be liable when a defect did not cause the crash but made the injuries worse. Your family must prove that a safer design was feasible.
A manufacturer is not sued for operating a motor vehicle, so there is an argument that the new fault rule does not protect it, though that question remains unsettled.
What New York Will Pay For, and What It Will Not
New York wrongful death damages are limited to financial losses, which the law calls pecuniary loss. They cover:
- Lost income and support,
- Lost household services,
- The guidance a parent would have given children,
- Funeral costs, and
- Medical bills with interest from the date of death.
Punitive damages, which punish especially wrongful conduct, may be available if your loved one could have recovered them. No-fault coverage may also pay medical expenses and a $2,000 death benefit, regardless of who caused the crash. However, the law does not pay your family for grief.
The Power of Evidence
Proof of your loved one’s daily life is therefore central. A grandmother’s care for her family can carry real value, even when her relatives were financially independent adults.
Survival Claims
The estate may also bring a separate survival claim for what your loved one personally endured. Conscious pain and suffering requires proof that your loved one was aware between the injury and death. New York also recognizes preimpact terror, the fear of a person who saw the crash coming. In an underride case, skid marks, brake data, and a swerve can be relevant to that question.
Evidence That Leaves the Scene on a Flatbed
The most important evidence in an underride case may be metal. A trailer can be repaired and sent back on the road, and the totaled car can be sold for salvage within days. Part of our job is sending preservation demands for the trailer, the guard, its mounting hardware, and the car before that happens.
The records have short lives too. A carrier may discard hours-of-service records after six months, and some inspection reports sooner. The car’s event data record can show speed and braking in the final seconds. New York generally allows retrieval with the owner’s consent or a court order, so do not sign away the car or its data before speaking with a lawyer.
Speaking for the One Witness Who Cannot Testify
After a fatal crash, the truck driver can give a statement, and your loved one cannot. The work of an underride accident lawyer Buffalo families hire is to answer the imbalance with the evidence that remains, including the trailer, the data, and the road itself. That evidence will not wait for a family to be ready. A trailer can return to service, a damaged car can be sold for salvage, and some records can lawfully be discarded within months. The two-year deadline to sue may feel distant, but the evidence can disappear much sooner.
New York Auto Law works to speak for the person who can no longer speak, so that the trucking company’s account is not the only version of how your loved one died. Contact our team today for a free consultation.
Legal References Used to Inform This Page
To ensure the accuracy and clarity of this page, we referenced official legal and other resources during the content development process:
- Rear impact guards and rear-end protection, 49 CFR 393.86.
- Rear impact guards and rear impact protection standards, 49 C.F.R. § 571.223.
- Rear impact protection, 49 C.F.R. § 571.224.
- H.R. 7354, Stop Underrides Act 2.0, 119th Cong. (2026).
- Action by personal representative for wrongful act, neglect, N.Y. Est. Powers & Trusts Law § 5-4.1 (2014).
- Action for injury to person or property survives despite death, N.Y. Est. Powers & Trusts Law §§ 11-3.2(a), (b) (2014).
- Death of claimant or person liable; cause of action accruing after death and before grant of letters, N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 210(b) (2014).
- Amount of recovery, N.Y. Est. Powers & Trusts Law § 5-4.3 (2014).
- Distribution of damages recovered, N.Y. Est. Powers & Trusts Law § 5-4.4 (2024).
- Application to compromise action, N.Y. Est. Powers & Trusts Law § 5-4.6 (2022).
- Emergency signals; stopped commercial motor vehicles, 49 C.F.R. § 392.22.
- Hazardous conditions; extreme caution, 49 C.F.R. § 392.14.
- Causes of action for personal injury, N.Y. Ins. Law § 5104(a) (2026).
- Damages recoverable when contributory negligence or assumption of risk is established, N.Y. C.P.L.R. § 1411(b) (2026).
- Negligence in use or operation of vehicle attributable to owner, N.Y. Veh. & Traf. Law § 388 (2023).
- Following too closely, N.Y. Veh. & Traf. Law § 1129(a) (2014).
- Graves Amendment, 49 U.S.C. § 30106.
- Stopping, standing, or parking outside of business or residence districts, N.Y. Veh. & Traf. Law § 1201 (McKinney 2014).
- Noseworthy v. City of New York, 298 N.Y. 76 (1948).

